Talk:Laraelra Harsard

Member of Moonstars?
(I always understood that they reformed a VERY DIFFERENT kind of Moonstar but with the same name (not being capable to decide a new name), also from successive source and Candlekeep Forum there are no indication about a different organization) (for example I know there is a elven wizard during the Sundering that belong to the Moonstars, and I always believed were the Renaer's group). --93.47.57.242, August 27, 2015


 * Renaer's group did not decide on a name (see p. 305 of Blackstaff Tower). Renaer's idea was to base the group on the Moonstars, but Vajra Safahr wanted it to have a different relationship with the Blackstaff and Parlek Lateriff argued against using the name "Moonstars". The group then discussed using the name Red Sashes and decided that wouldn't work either (p.303–304). So based on that, I don't think we can come to the conclusion that Renaer reformed the Moonstars, especially since they decided not to use the name Moonstars and had goals that were somewhat different. There also doesn't appear to be any connection between Renaer's group and the Moonstar in The Reaver (who is an elf and could very have well been part of the original Moonstars). However, if you have other sources that indicate otherwise, I would love to see them! —Coswig (talk) 20:41, August 27, 2015 (UTC)

My main concerne was that the Renaer's group for what I know was never mentioned again but in "The Reaver" and "The Herald" we had more Moonstars on the show, remember that mission of the elf Moonstar in the Reaver was protect a boy Chosen, and proliferation of Chosen was a Sundering's thing, so someone in circa 1480 had send her on mission, clearly not Khelben; unfortunately I can't fully read the Herald, where maybe were answers. The true problem was the name, WHY the author not name them in his book? In my opinion in early 4th edition they want create a new group but after they change mind and Wizards editors decided for reformation of Moonstars in prevision for 5th; for what you tell in that discussion only one guy was totally against use Moonstars, maybe later change mind, the true problem was "What happened to Ranear and his friends?", I had no clear answer but my impression was that as retcon they were Moonstars


 * It's very possible. However, until there is clear evidence to suggest otherwise, we can't call them Moonstars. —Coswig (talk) 21:59, August 27, 2015 (UTC)

Yes, I understand your position but I fear that we NEVER know answers to this question