User talk:Fw190a8

Archive of older comments

 * Archive created on 2007-03-19
 * Archive created on 2007-04-12
 * Archive created on 2008-01-05
 * Archive created on 2008-07-14
 * Archive created on 2009-09-21

DnD footer
I have updated the gaming footer to DnD centric links, you can add it by adding this code  to the bottom of the main page.

If there are any wikis I missed, they can be added here: w:Template:dndfooter --Sxerks 00:20, September 17, 2009 (UTC)

For Icingdeath, it's on page 46 of Silent Blade, but I dont' know how to cite sources.

Silent Balde edition
The Legend of Drizzt Book XI, ISBN: 978-0-7869-5054-6

Avariel Page
Thanks for the clean-up on my edits. I'll try to stick to that format if I add anymore, but I cant promise I'll get it right. I was actually just trying to reword the info to be a little more true to the descriptions in the manuals. There are other aspects such as where they are found and relationships to other creatures that could be explored, but didnt know if you had a set format and didnt want to create other headers that might break with any said format.

Deleting Clan Macrae image on userpage.
Hey there, You deleted an image from my user page that you shouldn't have. The picture is of and about my family and as such I am free to use it however I please, so please don't do it again. --Macrae 22:26, October 12, 2009 (UTC)

In response to your query
I've been a bit busy of late, but I'm still paying attention to the wiki. School's become a priority as of late, however. You know how life is. ;) Niirfa-sa 05:19, October 13, 2009 (UTC)

Re: I see you
Hehe, hey Focke, how've ya been? :) Zeraktalk 22:22, October 17, 2009 (UTC)

Hello
I need your help

I started a Forgotten Realms Wiki and I need people to come and help make it presentable and make articles and everything...

Maybe if you can help, just askin'...

PsykoReaper 00:48, October 27, 2009 (UTC)


 * Why would you need to create a Forgotten Realms Wiki when a perfectly good one already exists? Fw190a8 (talk &middot; contr) 18:16, October 27, 2009 (UTC)

RE: References Great Dale
Is that what you’ve meant? Advise me accordingly.Thank you.--Looptop 21:24, October 27, 2009 (UTC)

Yo!
It's good to be back, man. VERY good to be back. hashtalk 21:41, October 27, 2009 (UTC)

Deleted pages reborn
Wouldn't it be interesting to add a page listing all the deleted (well not the spam) pages to the Adding Content section of the Main Page, just like the ones that exist for "stubs" and "wanted pages" so that they could be improved and then posted?
 * You can see the list of deleted pages in the log here http://forgottenrealms.wikia.com/index.php?title=Special%3ALog&type=delete&user=&page=&year=&month=-1&hide_patrol_log=1 but it seems cumbersome to want to recreate articles from that list, since a lot of it is 1 random spam, 2 copyright violations 3 deleted for policy violations 4 deleted because a page was moved, mis-named etc. etc. Also, please sign your talk page comments by adding four tildes (~) Zeraktalk 15:09, November 11, 2009 (UTC)
 * Thank you for your answer. I thought the idea was interesting as users could recorrect plagiated pages without having to rewrite the whole page. I reckon it is a difficult balance to have both a detailed and unplagiated page, as every bit of information will inevitably have been drawn from a copyright-protected document (eg. Hasbro/WotC) Duneth 15:49, November 22, 2009 (UTC)
 * Basically the reasoning behind deleting plagiarised pages is that otherwise, someone could use the 'history' tab to view plagiarised material, so in the interests of respecting copyrights, we will delete plagiarism and force the article to be created in a way that respects copyrights. Fw190a8 (talk &middot; contr) 14:04, February 15, 2010 (UTC)

Overly non-canonical stuff
I am not sure if this is actually against the rules, but should lore created by random people be allowed here? I mean, seeing all these damn NWN and BG pages is annoying (Don't get me wrong, the games themselves are great, I play them, but annoying inconsistencies arise from their stories. I mean, how the hell did a Drow matron manage to bind an arch-devil???), but at least they have proper writers. This query is, more specifically, referring to the majority of the links on Starsword's User Page... Wereguy2 07:04, January 14, 2010 (UTC)

Need Help
An interesting choice of callsign. If I follow your example you could call me UH60L but that's not why I stopped by. I'm brand new to wikis and have never contributed to any before but I find myself with some spare time between flights these days and thought this would be a good thing to use to fill that block. I've expreimented with editing several posts but find that I need to start referencing my edits. I have read the help section on citations and have used the longhand formula to reference a couple of books. However, nowhere could I find instructions on how to permanently save those citation templates for use by other editors and the only thing mentioned was 'ask to have one created for you.' Any help you could give would be great. Thanks!--Crazyhorse75 15:04, February 18, 2010 (UTC)

Pages needing deletion
You might want to check out Category:Articles nominated for deletion. ➳ Quin 01:59, May 29, 2010 (UTC)

Citation Issue - Semberflow
I am wonder how you do a citation off of a map? The info for the Semberflow starting at Lake Sember and going to the Ashaba comes just from looking at the map. Lethalox 13:01, July 11, 2010 (UTC)

Pool of Radiance adventure book
I wouldn't be the one to ask if it was canon; WotC would. However, it's been treated as if it was canon in all subsequent sources. The relevant text has actually been entirely reprinted in Dungeon #170, so I should probably change the citation to that. -- Rowan Earthwood 16:35, July 25, 2010 (UTC)

Spell templates on non-spell articles: I agree
I agree with your assessment. We could also do with a similar template for magic items (I used the spell template for "Ring of enduring arcana" and "Belt of priestly might"). Maybe a catch-all template for such enchantments and items is in order. Perhaps something like the creature template, wherein the article type (Weapon Quality, Ring, Boots, and so on) appears at the top. (In the creature template, the creature's type appears in small print at the top.) StarSword 20:21, July 27, 2010 (UTC)

I've almost got a template completed at Template:Magic item, but it's having a little trouble. What's with this text:  {{ #if:1st|  StarSword 03:58, July 28, 2010 (UTC)

Q’arlynd Melarn
Although not cited, this edit is correct. Can’t you simply put the   tag at the end of that paragraph instead of removing it? ➳ Quin 22:46, September 28, 2010 (UTC)

Images
Sorry about not responding didnt notice I had mail. I have started putting down the source website normally amazon or wizards.com for the images and also amended them to show as book covers. Do I need to do anything else

Quenthel Baenre
Sorry about that, didn't mean to alter the class. Bowser64 19:00, October 9, 2010 (UTC)

Thankyou
Thanks for the feedback Fw190a8. My contributions are small but I'm grateful for any advice and help you(or others) can give me on helping this wiki to grow. --Eli the Tanner 20:09, October 13, 2010 (UTC)

Wikia's new skin
With Wikia making big changes to their skin (making an Oasis-based skin default), I was wondering what, if any, steps you're taking to preserve the format of this beloved wiki. I (and apparently many, many others) dislike (hate) the way the new skin looks, what with it removing so much content space, and I'm really hoping there's a way for you to save the current skin. Please let us know! Cronje 13:32, October 14, 2010 (UTC)


 * According to Sannse's blog, the new skin rolls out today, but that we can revert to Monaco until November 3rd. This would seem to imply that it will become mandatory beyond that point. Cronje 07:57, October 20, 2010 (UTC)


 * Aside from two things (detailed here), I wouldn't mind the skin at all.


 * I see a big problem: with the disappearance of the menu bar on the left, the Help page link on the homepage is missing for anyone not logged in, and even for those that are, its hidden in the user menu. At least the section "Helping Out" should have a link to it. Pruano 14:54, October 22, 2010 (UTC)

Citing Dungeon Magazine
What is the best way to cite Dungeon Magazine articles? Lethalox 21:31, October 15, 2010 (UTC)

I think the cite for Dungeon Magazine needs to be change to reflect pre-Paizo publishing of the magazine. Lethalox 01:05, October 16, 2010 (UTC)

de:1362 TZ
What does the bracketed code "de:1362 TZ" do to a document?Lethalox 01:35, October 16, 2010 (UTC)

Empty year pages
Year pages with only the template info are hardly devoid of info; they have the name of the year and era, which may not be so easy to find (as a matter of fact, the two most common links, and supposedly official) throughout the internet are broken (and havent found a new official one in the wizards site); it was by chance that i found this one which is the source i use (but no direct mention is done for it as far as i could find, more like a beta tool, like the encounter one).

Second, the Year pages have a very specific format, due to the template, and some of it (namely the sorting key for the Years category) isnt obvious.

Third, IMHO it WILL help improve the wiki, simply because then some of the work is already done; if a person has to go through the creation of a year page (with its specific format, and attached info) just to add an entry, they will most likely not bother; if the page is already created though, one only has to check other likely pages for that specific addition.

Fourth, the creation of the year pages (without current references) is very mechanical, and my current process makes this a quick process (the automation of such process, which i was in the process of implementing, makes such process even faster and less error prone than a manual entry).

But if you believe it does more harm than good, i will gladly stop; less work for me.

For the record, i hardly care about the wiki count; i care for the info i get from it, and as such, i agree that much work is required to bring the wiki to a more acceptable shape; thus i have fixed and added other info besides the "empty" year pages; i just dont think they are as useless as that, or i wouldnt bother.

As much as i would like a treaty on each and every one of the major (and minor) articles, they most likely wont happen, neither is that the nature of a wiki, which is more about collecting small contributions from the masses, which collectively will amount to such treaties IMHO  Pruano 23:21, October 16, 2010 (UTC)


 * As for the calendar link, using the Google search parameter "link:" only gives this link, and a similar search on that one gives no results at all. Pruano 23:37, October 16, 2010 (UTC)

Notes vs References
When should use Notes vs References? I saw that you edited -1715 DR and changed it.Lethalox 01:45, October 17, 2010 (UTC)

Quotes around references
Why is it important? I am happy to do it, but I would just like to understand the benefit it brings. Lethalox 01:47, October 17, 2010 (UTC)

Desert of Desolation
Yeah, Tracy and Laura Hickman's original modules were generic, but the compiled version of the module was explicitly set in the Forgotten Realms, in the desert of Raurin. Bakar, the nation whose ruins the PCs explore in the module, is mentioned in The Horde boxed set as an Imaskari successor state in Raurin. Desert of Desolation mentions neighboring Faerunian nations and geography, has heavy involvement with Durpari merchants, and even uses Elminster as a hook to get the PCs involved.-- Rowan Earthwood 16:08, October 18, 2010 (UTC)


 * Desert of Desolation is already listed in Portal:Sourcebooks, but as a 2nd edition module. This is inaccurate; it was published in 1987, firmly in the 1e era. -- Rowan Earthwood 16:19, October 18, 2010 (UTC)

Featured articles
No prob. I just noticed the update and so made one of my own. Niirfa-sa 19:09, October 18, 2010 (UTC)

Quotes
I can see your point. Mostly, I've been trying to go with giving the articles some flavor (as Wookieepedia does with many of its articles) but I do see your point. While I think we're too few in number to really have flame wars on the subject, if you'd like them removed, I'll go ahead and see to it. Niirfa-sa 19:22, October 19, 2010 (UTC)

Okay. I can kind of agree with what you're saying. I'll see about removing the quotes and not placing any more at the head of an article from now on. Niirfa-sa 19:31, October 19, 2010 (UTC)

References in Novels
Will do. I just could not remember where in the book and I am traveling this week so I don't have it with me. 24.114.255.99 19:47, October 19, 2010 (UTC)

Dead languages and tense
If you'll note the way Wikipedia speaks of dead languages (for example, Latin, Old English, and Old Norse), you'll see it uses the present tense. This is because while a dead human no longer exists as a human, a "dead" language still exists as long as it's written down. Some aspects of these languages should use the past tense, of course ("was commonly spoken throughout Jhaamdath" rather than "is spoken," for example; but even then, you can say "Jhaamdathan is a language that was once commmonly spoken" - it's still a language, whether people remember it or not). If scholars are still writing, speaking (even if mispronounced), and translating it, or if it can still be found on the walls of ancient ruins, the present tense is generally appropriate. -- Rowan Earthwood 19:05, October 24, 2010 (UTC)

Notes vs References
I noticed that you are changing articles (especially Years documents) from having a "Notes" section to "References". When should one be used over another? Lethalox 14:01, October 25, 2010 (UTC)

Ok. Good to know. Lethalox 14:20, October 25, 2010 (UTC)