Talk:Battle of Menzoberranzan

Nominated: Deletion
Here's why: -Coswig (talk) 00:20, February 16, 2014 (UTC)
 * 1) Unsourced: This page is unsourced. (Those numbers and descriptions certainly don't came from the War of the Spider Queen novels!)
 * 2) Misleading: There is no single "Battle of Menzoberranzan." This page refers to at least three events, including the slave revolt that takes place in Dissolution, the Battle of the Pillars of Woe (more info at Army of the Black Spider), and the Siege of Menzoberranzan.
 * 3) Redundant: I've created a new page called Siege of Menzoberranzan, which details the siege and summarizes the slave revolt and the Battle of the Pillars of Woe. The page more properly encompasses the conflict, which took place over several months. All of the relevant information is located at the new page. The new page is, however, missing the numbers from this page, but I have no idea where they come from and couldn't find them in any online searches.
 * 4) Messy: This page is more or less incomprehensible.


 * Excellent work, Cos... plus the page is filled with game crunch... deleted!!! - Darkwynters (talk) 00:42, February 16, 2014 (UTC)