Talk:Gates of the Moon

Ysgard/Gates of the Moon
The first line of the article states, "The Gates of the Moon, also known as Ysgard," and is cited as being information from page 170 of On Hallowed Ground. However, unless I misunderstand how planes work, Gates of the Moon is a layer of Ysgard, not the same plane (according to that source, which clearly states "Home [Plane/Layer/Realm]: Ysgard/Ysgard/Gates of the Moon").

If I'm not mistaken, a simple edit will fix this article (something like "The Gates of the Moon, a layer of the plane of Ysgard "). If not, then the Ysgard article needs to be redirected here and maybe combined with the Gladsheim article.

Anyone have any thoughts? 68.36.46.141 22:37, March 4, 2014 (UTC)


 * Unknown "Realmslore master" User... personally, I am not sure... good Master Movie can probably fix your problem... all I can say is create a profile... Please :) - Darkwynters (talk) 22:42, March 4, 2014 (UTC)


 * This article is on my list to get an overhaul, it is a mishmash of information from various editions. In 2nd edition as described by On Hallowed Ground, Gates of the Moon is the Realm of Selûne in the Layer of Ysgard on the Plane of Ysgard, which is confusing all by itself. As described by the Forgotten Realms Campaign Setting 2nd edition (revised) on page 52 of the Running the Realms booklet, it says she resides in Gladsheim (1st edition also says Gladsheim). By 3rd edition, Gates of the Moon is its own plane connected to the World Tree, and in 4th edition it is floating in the Astral Sea. This article will pick up where the Gladsheim/Ysgard article leaves off. I'm just going to remove the Ysgard reference for now. &mdash;Moviesign (talk) 01:37, March 5, 2014 (UTC)