Talk:Black Bastion

Article in title?
Bane's divine realm is called "The Black Bastion" in Faiths & Avatars. Is there any guideline, should the article title (or in this case, redirect) include the article or not? Thanks for input! Daranios (talk) 19:47, October 9, 2017 (UTC)


 * We've had this discussion on and off for a while, usually regarding inns and taverns. IME, we've generally been ignoring definite (the) and indefinite (a, an) articles at the beginnings of page-names, unless it's provably a part of the proper name. It has its benefits. It's more natural to search for "Black Bastion" than "The Black Bastion". If you want to write something like "Bane resided at the imposing Black Bastion", it's simpler to write " the imposing Black Bastion " than " the imposing Black Bastion ". It also doesn't require adjusting category sorting to alphabetise it.


 * On the other hand, simply listing "Black Bastion" in an infobox, list of places, or category, may look odd, whereas "The Black Bastion" may feel more natural and appropriate, emphasising a singular, unique nature. There are also those inns and taverns where "The" may well be part of the name on the sign and probably ought to be included.


 * I've usually argued for the former, but these days I don't think there's a universal solution or rule one way or the other. Having redirects for both forms seems redundant. Go with your heart. :D — BadCatMan (talk) 00:45, October 10, 2017 (UTC)