Talk:Nameless One

Thought this is a FR Wiki. What does the character of PST have to do with the Realms? Is there any important detail in some PS novel or other stuff, which makes him interesting for this Wiki? Besides the Realms had their own "Nameless One" during the fall of Myth Drannor, if I am not mistaken he became Khelben when he was ressurected or so. Historicus 20:02, 13 January 2009 (UTC)
 * Though I haven't played PST I'd be open to the possibility of the Nameless One being a part of the wiki, since we've established Sigil to be canonical in relation to the Realms. However, I understand it's a gray area since, technically, PST takes place in Planescape, and even if Planescape overlaps significantly with the other campaign settings it's debatable as to whether or not we should include the Nameless One and similar articles.
 * That said, we do have an article on Annah. Niirfa-sa 20:20, 13 January 2009 (UTC)


 * I wrote it because I wanted to. It is already established that the city of Sigil is canonical and exists in the Forgotten Realms universe, seeing as there is an entire sourcebook availble for purchase.  It is not really my fault that this enviroment was not fully explored by the corporate goons of Wizards.  I like to give background information on characters and events that others may want to use as source material for campaigns and modules.  This is NOT an attempt to turn this into a "video game" wiki or anything of that nature.  It is for informational purposes only.
 * On a personal note, this is rather insulting. I have submitted many articles for this Wiki that all seem to draw criticism and debate.  Let me clarify my feelings on this:  No one that has made comments like this "owns" this page.  Therefore, no one has any right to determine what should and shouldn't go on it.  I welcome edits for fixing possible mistakes and corrections of grammar and spelling, but please leave discussions of content in a private format.  I do this on my own time, on a volunteer basis.  It is almost to the point of asking myself:  Why do I bother? - Dark Ronin
 * p.s. I wrote that article on Annah as well. Expect one shortly on Morte, unless I get discouraged and just quit trying to help.


 * Dark Ronin, your contributions specific to Forgotten Realms content are always welcome on this wiki. And I've seen that you contribute quite a lot as well, which is very appreciated btw! And you are correct that there is no person that "owns" this article/page, so anyone can make edits.  I think the issue for some people is that this article does not cite anything specific to FR.  Here's my take on it: Yes, Sigil is part of FR.  So is Spelljammer.  That's because we have FR-specific references for them.  But as an example, we have chosen not to document every single Spelljammer vessel (this isn't a Spelljammer wiki after all).
 * Also, since both Toril (FR) and Oerth (Greyhawk) are connected via Spelljammer, one could make the argument that it's okay to start adding articles about Mordenkainen, Bigby, and the rest of the Circle of Eight. Clearly we wouldn't want that.  I hope you can see the analogy and how this relates to Planescape and its inhabitants.
 * This is just my take on it, and I'm not anyone special on this wiki. But elsewhere (here and here), others have more or less agreed that we need to have FR-specific references in order to consider it be "canon" and included on this wiki.  In any case, I hope that you at least understand this point of view.  Cheers,  15:40, 14 January 2009 (UTC)
 * Agreed. The only reference to The Nameless One from a Forgotten Realms perspective would be Baldur's Gate II which, in itself is non-canonical. hashtalk 15:43, 14 January 2009 (UTC)
 * Actually, wasn't the consensus that the Baldur's Gate games were canonical so far as they did not violate the more inviolable canon of the novels? I can't say I've played the games in detail so I don't know if the reference violates the novels or not - but in such a case it would seem the Nameless One could merit an article. However, if the reference is something incompatible with the novels, then obviously the article has no merit (or at least none more than Annah's). Niirfa-sa 19:50, 14 January 2009 (UTC)


 * Our canon policy is a little vague on this subject, but here's an excerpt: "Apart from the CRPGs yet to be discussed, CRPGs are to be considered non-canon". They also mention that video games should use the non-canon templates.
 * But getting back to the subject at hand. If we cite Baldur's Gate as a reference (btw, where do they mention the Nameless One in BG II SoA?) and we put a "non-canon" template on this article, then I guess it might meet the requirements for inclusion on this wiki.  It might at least be a reasonable compromise.  21:27, 14 January 2009 (UTC)
 * One of the merchants in Athkatla (if you bought the special edition of the game) sold items from Planescape: Torment each of which referenced various characters (including the Nameless One) in the item description. hashtalk 22:03, 14 January 2009 (UTC)