Talk:Aribeth de Tylmarande

Race
Eh, actually even the text says both that she's elven and that she is half-elven. Ville V. Kokko 07:49, 13 April 2007 (UTC)
 * This article calls her "half-eladrin." Retconning of the apocryphal events that lead into the entirely different world of the 4th edition Toril need not be done. Neverwinter Nights was a 3rd edition game. Aribeth was (Half)-ELF, not half-Eladrin. Elves are the player race, Eladrin are a bunch of fey-celestial outsiders, the CG equivalent of Archons. It is inaccurate to use 4th edition terminology in regard to a character who was created for 3rd edition.
 * Love it or hate it, 4th edition is canon and moon elves are eladrin. Niirfa-sa 09:03, December 5, 2009 (UTC)
 * "These fey folk collectively call themselves eladrin, and many Faerûnian elves have also adopted this name for their lineage, though they have not forgotten their traditional cultural distinctions and names. In casual speech, the world “elven” collectively refers to the two branches of this fey people: elves and eladrin" (from: ). So, I think using half-eladrin is totally unnecessary. Mpj 01:30, August 12, 2011 (UTC)
 * Love it or hate it, WotC does not retcon all their books they released during the time before 4:th edition came out either. This is "Forgotten Realms Wikia", NOT "Dungeons & Dragons latest edition Wikia" hence the character, which hasn't been changed in any later edition and is only mentioned in 3:d edition contexts at all, should be described according to said terminology.--Baalzie (talk) 05:01, January 28, 2014 (UTC)